Autism in Heels: Difference between revisions

From ms-demeanor.com
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "Jennifer Cook. 2018. Memoir. 272 pages, 249min reading time, read on 11/8/2026.")
 
No edit summary
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Jennifer Cook. 2018. Memoir.
Jennifer Cook. 2018. Memoir.
272 pages, 249min reading time, read on 11/8/2026.
272 pages, 249min reading time, read on 11/8/2026.
About halfway through this book Jennifer Cook explains executive function through a metaphor about Santa Claus. This rather strained attempt at keeping things light really demonstrates that Cook is, primarily, a children's author. As such, she is used to talking down to her audience, which explains why the front half of this book is so grating.
There's a really significant tone problem with a lot of the memoir. The last couple of chapters, in which Cook is more vulnerable and less confident, is a lot more pleasant to read.
It's bit frustrating that Cook's experiences are presented in such an irksome tone because the experiences she describes likely mirror a lot of people who have been passed over for diagnosis or marginalized in autistic spaces because of their gender.
Also, Cook uses two bugfuck insane analogies:
* Early in the book she compares autistic overstimulation to slaves running from plantations. (The analogy likens Autistic people's need to get away from overstimulating environments as nonsensical and ridiculous to NT people the way that slaves fleeing slavery seemed nonsensical and ridiculous to slaveholders.)
* Later in the book, she compares the way that attractive women are excluded from feminist/disability movements to the way that black women were excluded from the Suffrage movement, literally quoting Sojourner Truth and applying "ain't I a woman?" to the way she feels left out of conversations about disability because she's pretty.
Reading these parts felt deeply jarring. That dissonance speaks to the tone problem the book has; Cook thinks very highly of herself, she thinks fairly poorly of her readers, and she sees the struggles she deals with as a modern, autistic white woman with an Ivy League education and a job in television production as worthy of evoking chattel slavery in order to make an apt comparison. 
Anyway, here's a direct transcription of a quote that stood out to me as exemplary of the problems with the book. This is Cook describing how her daughter's psychologist spoke to Jennifer after confirming the daughter's autism diagnosis.
"I didn't see your daughter's Asperger's at first. The boys? Absolutely. But not her,' she admitted calmly and then leaned in. 'But, you made the case, point by pint, and asked me to stick around without judgement for a month or so. You were tired and had been through a wringer of psychologists and specialists and I'll be honest, I thought you were wrong about her. Jennifer, you weren't. Every observation was spot on and, four years later, not only do I have no doubt about her Asperger's, you taught me what some of the world's best medical schools couldn't.' She smiled and sighed. 'Be sure. By sharing your own journey, thousands upon thousands of girls will be blessed. You will be doubted, for certain, just as I doubted you at first. What I don't doubt, Jennifer, is that you will do anything to save hearts from suffering. So go out and teach the world, just as you've taught me."

Latest revision as of 12:18, 9 November 2026

Jennifer Cook. 2018. Memoir.

272 pages, 249min reading time, read on 11/8/2026.

About halfway through this book Jennifer Cook explains executive function through a metaphor about Santa Claus. This rather strained attempt at keeping things light really demonstrates that Cook is, primarily, a children's author. As such, she is used to talking down to her audience, which explains why the front half of this book is so grating.

There's a really significant tone problem with a lot of the memoir. The last couple of chapters, in which Cook is more vulnerable and less confident, is a lot more pleasant to read.

It's bit frustrating that Cook's experiences are presented in such an irksome tone because the experiences she describes likely mirror a lot of people who have been passed over for diagnosis or marginalized in autistic spaces because of their gender.

Also, Cook uses two bugfuck insane analogies:

  • Early in the book she compares autistic overstimulation to slaves running from plantations. (The analogy likens Autistic people's need to get away from overstimulating environments as nonsensical and ridiculous to NT people the way that slaves fleeing slavery seemed nonsensical and ridiculous to slaveholders.)
  • Later in the book, she compares the way that attractive women are excluded from feminist/disability movements to the way that black women were excluded from the Suffrage movement, literally quoting Sojourner Truth and applying "ain't I a woman?" to the way she feels left out of conversations about disability because she's pretty.

Reading these parts felt deeply jarring. That dissonance speaks to the tone problem the book has; Cook thinks very highly of herself, she thinks fairly poorly of her readers, and she sees the struggles she deals with as a modern, autistic white woman with an Ivy League education and a job in television production as worthy of evoking chattel slavery in order to make an apt comparison.

Anyway, here's a direct transcription of a quote that stood out to me as exemplary of the problems with the book. This is Cook describing how her daughter's psychologist spoke to Jennifer after confirming the daughter's autism diagnosis.

"I didn't see your daughter's Asperger's at first. The boys? Absolutely. But not her,' she admitted calmly and then leaned in. 'But, you made the case, point by pint, and asked me to stick around without judgement for a month or so. You were tired and had been through a wringer of psychologists and specialists and I'll be honest, I thought you were wrong about her. Jennifer, you weren't. Every observation was spot on and, four years later, not only do I have no doubt about her Asperger's, you taught me what some of the world's best medical schools couldn't.' She smiled and sighed. 'Be sure. By sharing your own journey, thousands upon thousands of girls will be blessed. You will be doubted, for certain, just as I doubted you at first. What I don't doubt, Jennifer, is that you will do anything to save hearts from suffering. So go out and teach the world, just as you've taught me."